Boston Real Estate: What Insurance Covers in a Fire

Boston Real Estate: What Insurance Covers in a Fire

00:00

• 1

  Boston Real Estate: What Insurance Covers in a Fire

Fire damage is one of the most significant risks for landlords, property owners, and property managers in Boston. In a city with a high concentration of multi-family homes, apartment buildings, and historic properties, fires can spread rapidly, causing extensive property damage and financial losses. According to WBUR, Massachusetts recorded 51 fire-related deaths in 2024, the highest number in over a decade. Fire incidents caused more than $300 million in property losses, with residential fires making up 73% of all reported incidents.

Understanding what fire insurance covers is critical for protecting real estate investments. Many landlords assume that their insurance policy will cover all fire-related losses, but that is not always the case. Standard fire insurance policies typically include structural damage, loss of rental income, landlord-owned property, and liability protection. However, there are common exclusions that can leave property owners financially vulnerable. Ensuring adequate coverage requires reviewing policy limits, understanding exclusions, and considering optional endorsements to provide comprehensive protection.

Understanding Fire Insurance for Rental Properties in Boston

Fire insurance is a critical component of landlord insurance, specifically designed to cover rental properties against fire-related losses. While homeowners’ insurance protects owner-occupied residences, landlord insurance is tailored to safeguard investment properties by addressing the unique risks associated with renting to tenants. Standard policies not only cover damage caused by fire but also protect against related hazards such as smoke damage, water damage from firefighting efforts, and in some cases, temporary relocation costs for tenants.

A recent study from claimguide.org found that Massachusetts is home to the most cooking fires per capita, with an average of 13,137 cooking fires occurring each year (188.2 cooking fires per 100,000 residents)

In Boston, the cost of landlord insurance is influenced by several factors, including the property's age, location, size, and construction materials. Older buildings, particularly those constructed before modern fire safety codes, tend to have higher premiums due to outdated wiring, aging heating systems, and structural vulnerabilities that increase fire risk. Additionally, properties with multiple rental units often have higher insurance costs due to increased occupancy, which raises the likelihood of accidental fires.

Insurers also consider fire station proximity, with properties located farther from emergency response services facing higher premiums. While standard policies offer protection for most fire-related incidents, landlords should carefully review their coverage limits, exclusions, and optional endorsements to ensure their property is adequately insured against potential losses. Regular policy updates are necessary to account for changes in property value, inflation, and updated building codes that may impact rebuilding costs.

Dwelling Coverage: Protecting the Structure of the Property

Dwelling coverage is the most critical aspect of fire insurance, as it provides financial protection for repairing or rebuilding the rental property after a fire. This coverage includes the building’s physical structure, including walls, roof, floors, ceilings, electrical and plumbing systems, and built-in appliances.

For multi-family properties in Boston, rebuilding costs can be substantial. Many landlords underestimate their rebuilding costs, leaving them financially exposed if their insurance coverage is too low.

To prevent coverage gaps, landlords should consider Extended Replacement Cost Endorsements, which provide an additional 20–25% above the policy limit in case of increased construction costs. Another important policy add-on is Ordinance or Law Coverage, which covers the expense of bringing a fire-damaged property up to current building codes.

Landlord-Owned Personal Property Coverage

While standard fire insurance covers the structure of the building, it does not automatically cover items owned by the landlord that are inside the rental property. This is where personal property coverage becomes important.

Landlord personal property coverage applies to:

• Appliances such as refrigerators, stoves, and dishwashers
• Furnishings in common areas, including lobby furniture and lighting
• Maintenance equipment such as lawn mowers and snow blowers

This coverage does not apply to tenant-owned property. If tenants want protection for their belongings, they must purchase renters’ insurance. Many landlords highly recommend renters’ insurance in lease agreements to ensure that tenants have coverage for personal property. The average renters’ insurance policy costs $15–$30 per month according to Mass.Gov.

Loss of Rental Income Coverage

A fire can render a property uninhabitable for months, leading to significant financial losses if rental income is not protected. Loss of rental income coverage, sometimes called rental reimbursement insurance, compensates landlords for lost income while repairs are being made.

For example, if a six-unit apartment building in Dorchester generates $2,500 per unit per month and a fire forces all tenants to vacate for six months, the landlord could lose $90,000 in rental income ($15,000 per month x 6 months). Without this coverage, the financial impact would be severe.  Most policies cover up to 12 months of lost rent, though extended coverage may be available. Landlords should verify whether their policy covers the actual rental income they receive or the fair market value of similar rental properties.

Liability Protection for Fire-Related Injuries

When a fire occurs in a rental property, the consequences extend beyond property damage. If tenants, visitors, or maintenance workers suffer injuries, the landlord may face legal and financial repercussions, especially if the fire is traced back to negligence. Liability protection within a landlord’s insurance policy provides coverage for medical bills, legal fees, and settlements in cases where the property owner is held responsible.

Boston landlords face heightened legal risks if fires result from faulty wiring, inadequate fire suppression systems, or the absence of functioning smoke detectors. Properties that do not meet local fire safety regulations can make landlords directly liable for tenant injuries. For instance, a fire caused by outdated electrical wiring in an older building could lead to a lawsuit if it is determined that the landlord failed to perform necessary upgrades. Additionally, if a property lacks properly maintained fire escapes or sprinkler systems, legal claims could escalate.

Data from the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) shows that in 2022, U.S. fire departments responded to 343,100 home structure fires, resulting in 2,620 civilian deaths and 11,110 injuries NFPA.

Many standard landlord policies provide only $100,000 in liability coverage, which may not be sufficient to cover extensive medical expenses, pain and suffering claims, or legal defense costs. To mitigate risks, landlords should increase their liability limits to at least $500,000 or $1 million. Additionally, securing an umbrella policy offers extra coverage beyond the standard policy limits at a relatively low premium. These additional layers of protection help ensure that landlords are not financially devastated by lawsuits resulting from fire-related injuries.

Common Exclusions in Fire Insurance Policies

Fire insurance provides critical protection for rental properties, but it does not cover every fire-related loss. Landlords must understand policy exclusions to avoid unexpected financial liabilities. Certain circumstances, such as deliberate acts, prolonged vacancies, or negligence, can result in denied claims. Reviewing policy terms and adding necessary endorsements can help landlords close these coverage gaps.

Arson or Intentional Fires

If a fire is deliberately set by the property owner or tenant, the insurance claim will be denied. Insurers investigate suspicious fires, and if fraud is suspected, not only will the claim be denied, but the responsible party could face criminal charges. According to the National Fire Protection Association, municipal fire departments in the United States responded to an estimated annual average of 52,260 intentionally set structure fires in the five-year period from 2014 to 2018.

Vacant Properties

Standard fire insurance may not cover losses if a rental unit is vacant for 30 days or more. Unoccupied buildings are at higher risk of vandalism, electrical failures, and delayed fire detection. Many insurers require a Vacancy Endorsement to maintain fire protection for vacant properties.

Negligence

Insurance companies may deny claims if a fire results from landlord negligence, such as ignoring outdated wiring, failing to install working smoke detectors, or violating fire codes. Landlords should conduct annual property inspections to ensure compliance with fire safety regulations.

Flood or Water Damage After a Fire

Fire insurance does not cover water damage from firefighting efforts or flooding caused by burst pipes after a fire. Landlords must purchase separate flood insurance to protect against water-related losses. Reviewing policies and adding necessary riders can prevent costly out-of-pocket expenses.

Enhancing Fire Insurance Coverage

Fire insurance policies provide basic protection, but landlords who want full financial security should consider key policy upgrades that address potential coverage gaps. Standard policies often have limits that may not fully cover the actual cost of rebuilding, legal liabilities, or the financial impact of tenant displacement. Expanding coverage through additional endorsements can significantly reduce financial risks associated with fire damage.

Extended Replacement Cost Coverage ensures landlords are not left paying out-of-pocket if rebuilding costs exceed the policy’s limit. Construction expenses fluctuate due to material shortages, inflation, and labor costs. This coverage provides an additional 20–25% above the stated policy limit to account for these increases, ensuring that landlords can fully restore their property after a fire without financial strain.

Ordinance & Law Coverage is essential for older buildings in Boston, as fire damage may trigger mandatory code upgrades. Even if only part of a building is damaged, insurers may not cover costs associated with bringing undamaged sections up to current safety standards. This endorsement covers expenses related to electrical, plumbing, and structural improvements required by updated building regulations.

Vacancy Endorsements prevent coverage lapses for unoccupied properties. Standard policies often exclude fire damage if a property is vacant for more than 30 days, making this upgrade critical for landlords with seasonal rentals or extended vacancies.

Higher Liability Limits protect against costly lawsuits if tenants or visitors suffer fire-related injuries. Increasing coverage beyond the standard $100,000 to at least $500,000 can prevent financial hardship from legal claims and settlements.

Preventing Fire Damage in Boston Rental Properties

While having the right insurance coverage is essential, landlords should also take proactive measures to minimize fire risks in their rental properties. Fires in multi-family buildings can spread quickly, making fire prevention a crucial responsibility for property owners. Boston’s aging housing stock, combined with high tenant turnover, increases the likelihood of fire hazards that can lead to significant property damage and tenant displacement.

One of the most common causes of residential fires is electrical issues, particularly in buildings over 40 years old. Many older properties still have knob-and-tube wiring, aluminum wiring, or outdated circuit breakers that are not designed to handle modern electrical loads. Overloaded outlets and extension cord misuse by tenants further increase fire risks. Landlords should hire licensed electricians to inspect and upgrade electrical systems, replacing outdated wiring and ensuring panels meet current safety codes.

Ranges or cooktops account for over half (53%) of home cooking fire incidents, according to the NFPA.

Many kitchen fires result from unattended cooking, grease buildup, or flammable items being placed near stovetops. Providing stove-top fire suppressors and educating tenants on safe cooking practices can significantly reduce these incidents.

Heating equipment failures are another leading cause of fires. Space heaters, old furnaces, and clogged chimneys can overheat or ignite nearby materials. Annual HVAC inspections, furnace cleaning, and providing safe heating guidelines for tenants help mitigate risks.

Smoking indoors remains a significant fire hazard, prompting Boston to ban smoking in public housing units in 2019. Landlords should implement a strict no-smoking policy in lease agreements and provide designated outdoor smoking areas with proper disposal receptacles.

To further reduce fire risks, landlords should install interconnected smoke detectors in every unit, ensuring they comply with Boston’s fire codes. Regular testing and battery replacements are necessary for functionality. Additionally, conducting annual fire inspections helps identify potential hazards before they become costly emergencies. Educating tenants on fire safety, including proper extinguisher use and evacuation procedures, enhances overall building safety.

Final Thoughts

Fire insurance is an essential safeguard for Boston landlords and property owners, offering critical financial protection against devastating fire-related losses. However, simply having a policy is not enough—understanding coverage limits, exclusions, and optional endorsements is key to ensuring full protection. The high risk of fires in multi-family buildings and historic properties makes it imperative for landlords to carefully review their policies and upgrade coverage where necessary.

Beyond insurance, proactive fire prevention measures can significantly reduce risks. Regular electrical inspections, updated heating systems, tenant education, and strict fire safety compliance all contribute to minimizing fire hazards. Landlords who take a comprehensive approach—combining robust insurance coverage with diligent property maintenance—stand the best chance of protecting both their investments and their tenants.

By staying informed, regularly updating policies, and implementing preventative fire safety measures, landlords in Boston can navigate the challenges of fire risks with confidence. In a city where fire-related losses continue to climb, being well-prepared can mean the difference between financial stability and devastating losses.

**Disclosure: Important Notice to Readers** The content provided in this blog is intended for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered as professional or legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation. We strive to offer accurate and up-to-date information, but the dynamic nature of the insurance industry means that some information may become outdated or inaccurate over time. We strongly recommend that readers seek the advice of a qualified insurance professional, financial advisor and legal professional before making any decisions regarding insurance policies, coverage, or any related financial matters. Each individual's circumstances are unique, and professional guidance can help tailor decisions to specific needs and goals. The authors and publishers of this blog disclaim any liability, loss, or risk incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, from the use and application of any of the information presented herein. Your reliance on any information provided on this blog is solely at your own risk.